Fandom Shirou Emiya's Smithing Shop - OOC

[Xel]

Well I said nobody can guess Caster's identity. I didn't say anything about the GM leaking it :|

 

[Iskandar]

Oh trust me. Unless there are other monkey men who qualify as Berserker I don't think you'll have troubles figuring out who it is.

I mean, I have a guess.Are they Chinese?

Well with an EX NP I only have one guess, unless it's EX for a ridiculous reason I never considered haha.

Yeah pretty sure I figured it out. )))

Good job Xel oh I'm making Caster's master. You probably already know that

 

[Xel]

Yeah pretty sure I figured it out. )))

Good job Xel oh I'm making Caster's master. You probably already know that

I noticed in the IC thread that you were listed as my Master lol.

 

[cojemo]

Personally, I don't care about strength or identities. Like the whole thing about powerlevels before annoyed me because this isn't a battle RP. Who cares if so and so can beat someone else? Personally if it were up to me I'd have all the Servants public so they can be discussed openly since that stuff is so much fun.

 

[Iskandar]

I noticed in the IC thread that you were listed as my Master lol.

I look forward to either dominating the competition or being destroyed with you!

 

[Xel]

Still, so far I've had nobody come forth and actually say who they think Caster is. Nor have I seen what this hint is. Just a lot of people saying they know.

 

[Dalamus Ulom]

Personally, I don't care about strength or identities. Like the whole thing about powerlevels before annoyed me because this isn't a battle RP. Who cares if so and so can beat someone else? Personally if it were up to me I'd have all the Servants public so they can be discussed openly since that stuff is so much fun.

But half the fun is piecing together all the tidbits and clues until you finally have for yourself an idea. I mean, we aren't passive observers of the Grail War, we are active participants. Easy clues usually won't be handed to you on a silver platter.

 

[cojemo]

But half the fun is piecing together all the tidbits and clues until you finally have for yourself an idea. I mean, we aren't passive observers of the Grail War, we are active participants. Easy clues usually won't be handed to you on a silver platter.

Well, technically we are just observers. Our characters are the participants. There won't be metagaming I hope, so what we know doesn't matter.

Still, so far I've had nobody come forth and actually say who they think Caster is. Nor have I seen what this hint is. Just a lot of people saying they know.

Straight up, you seem defensive about that for some reason. Don't be. It's RPing and these things don't matter. Plus you haven't said the identities of anyone else either, so yeah. We're simply not spoiling things in case we're right.

 

[Dalamus Ulom]

Well, technically we are just observers. Our characters are the participants. There won't be metagaming I hope, so what we know doesn't matter.

Straight up, you seem defensive about that for some reason. Don't be. It's RPing and these things don't matter. Plus you haven't said the identities of anyone else either, so yeah. We're simply not spoiling things in case we're right.

Alright, as close to active participants as is actually possible.

 

[Xel]

Well, technically we are just observers. Our characters are the participants. There won't be metagaming I hope, so what we know doesn't matter.

Straight up, you seem defensive about that for some reason. Don't be. It's RPing and these things don't matter. Plus you haven't said the identities of anyone else either, so yeah. We're simply not spoiling things in case we're right.

If I seem defensive it's because I am. I made sure not to leak my identity and the idea that the GM gave away confidential information makes me mad. If people know my identity because they did good detective work, so be it, that's part of the fun. But if they know because the GM all but told them, that's a gross breach of trust. And so far I've seen a bunch of people say the GM did exactly that.

 

[cojemo]

Alright, as close to active participants as is actually possible.

Yup. I mean come on, I've practically spelled out every single weakness and more that Jeremy has, so it should be obvious by now that the story and characters are more important to me than winning, haha.

 

[cojemo]

If I seem defensive it's because I am. I made sure not to leak my identity and the idea that the GM gave away confidential information makes me mad. If people know my identity because they did good detective work, so be it, that's part of the fun. But if they know because the GM all but told them, that's a gross breach of trust. And so far I've seen a bunch of people say the GM did exactly that.

I saw one person say that. And hey, don't worry if it's been leaked. In the end it doesn't matter, it's all in good fun right? You don't need to be mad about a mistake.

 

[Dalamus Ulom]

If I seem defensive it's because I am. I made sure not to leak my identity and the idea that the GM gave away confidential information makes me mad. If people know my identity because they did good detective work, so be it, that's part of the fun. But if they know because the GM all but told them, that's a gross breach of trust. And so far I've seen a bunch of people say the GM did exactly that.

All Birdsie said was that he didn't think A rank magic was right for Caster, and that it should be B rank. That instantly tossed out Team Assassin's admittedly shite first idea.

 

[Xel]

All Birdsie said was that he didn't think A rank magic was right for Caster, and that it should be B rank. That instantly tossed out our admittedly shite first idea.

Birdsie didn't say ranks, he only said to weaken the magic a bit. That's not a hint at all unless people thought you could have a magicless Caster or something....

 

[cojemo]

Birdsie didn't say ranks, he only said to weaken the magic a bit. That's not a hint at all unless people thought you could have a magicless Caster or something....

If you want my guess, with a EX NP it has to be someone super strong or well known unless they are strong for stupid reasons, so my only guess is Circe. That's all I got, so there ya go.

 

[Dalamus Ulom]

Birdsie didn't say ranks, he only said to weaken the magic a bit. That's not a hint at all unless people thought you could have a magicless Caster or something....

Actually, it's a huge clue, considering what we were working with. With A rank magic, you could have practically been any powerful mage from the bronze to early iron age. I'll admit now, our first idea was Circe. Telling us that it should have been B instantly tossed her out of the picture.

 

[Dalamus Ulom]

If you want my guess, with a EX NP it has to be someone super strong or well known unless they are strong for stupid reasons, so my only guess is Circe. That's all I got, so there ya go.

Actually, it's a huge clue, considering what we were working with. With A rank magic, you could have practically been any powerful mage from the bronze to early iron age. I'll admit now, our first idea was Circe. Telling us that it should have been B instantly tossed her out of the picture.

Well then. This is rather awkward.

 

[Iskandar]

Ooooh~ intriguing

 

[cojemo]

Well then. This is rather awkward.

Great minds think alike! And yeah, I've been with Xel in an RP before, and this isn't a slight at him but he sometimes makes his characters stronger than they should be, haha.

 

[Xel]

If you want my guess, with a EX NP it has to be someone super strong or well known unless they are strong for stupid reasons, so my only guess is Circe. That's all I got, so there ya go.

Actually, it's a huge clue, considering what we were working with. With A rank magic, you could have practically been any powerful mage from the bronze to early iron age. I'll admit now, our first idea was Circe. Telling us that it should have been B instantly tossed her out of the picture.

I see... Also again he didn't say lower magic to B rank. He just said to lower Caster's magical abilities slightly. But alright then, glad that's cleared up. I thought the "hint" was an actual hint. Glad it wasn't.

 

[cojemo]

I see... Also again he didn't say lower magic to B rank. He just said to lower Caster's magical abilities slightly. But alright then, glad that's cleared up. I thought the "hint" was an actual hint. Glad it wasn't.

You're not going to tell us if we were right? You meanie!

 

[Xel]

You're not going to tell us if we were right? You meanie!

All I'll say is I was right in that nobody will ever guess Caster's identity.

 

[Dalamus Ulom]

I see... Also again he didn't say lower magic to B rank. He just said to lower Caster's magical abilities slightly. But alright then, glad that's cleared up. I thought the "hint" was an actual hint. Glad it wasn't.

I mean, unless you made it A-, lowering it to B is the only thing that makes sense to me.

 

[Dalamus Ulom]

You're not going to tell us if we were right? You meanie!

All I'll say is I was right in that nobody will ever guess Caster's identity.

Like I said before, it instantly threw most of Team Assassin's theories out the window.

 

[cojemo]

I mean, unless you made it A-, lowering it to B is the only thing that makes sense to me.

Could have weakened that EX NP power.