Fandom Shirou Emiya's Smithing Shop - OOC

[Jean Otus]

The problem is your clues don't add up. You said he was the enemy of Selim I, however the only king of Hungary who reigned at the same time as Selim I was Validslaus II.

Enemy of his father, close, close

 

[Dalamus Ulom]

Not assuming anything, just stating the only valid reasons. You either don't know or you plan on metagaming, as you already mentioned it being an "advantage". Just be warned, I wont tolerate you metagaming with my identity.

So a guy can't simply be patient? Yeah I called in an advantage, but you're going and taking it a step further by saying that I'm trying to metagame. So stop making an ass out of yourself, because I'm not.

 

[Xel]

Enemy of his father, close, close

When someone mentioned Selaiman you said enemy of his father, Selaiman's father was Selim I. The only hungarian king to reign at the same time as Selim I was Vladislaus II

 

[Xel]

So a guy can't simply be patient? Yeah I called in an advantage, but you're going and taking it a step further by saying that I'm trying to metagame. So stop making an ass out of yourself, because I'm not.

How is knowing a servant's identity OOC, but not IC, an advantage if not through metagame? The answer is it's not. So you literally admitted to metagaming. :|

 

[Jean Otus]

When someone mentioned Selaiman you said enemy of his father, Selaiman's father was Selim I. The only hungarian king to reign at the same time as Selim I was Vladislaus II

I'm sorry I think I must have my lineages of the sultans mixed up. They all invaded Hungary so often it's hard to keep track of them.

 

[Xel]

I'm sorry I think I must have my lineages of the sultans mixed up. They all invaded Hungary so often it's hard to keep track of them.

That's why I'm confused rofl. If you got it turned around then I'd say Luis II is Ruler's identity.

 

[HTCOR]

How is knowing a servant's identity OOC, but not IC, an advantage if not through metagame? The answer is it's not. So you literally admitted to metagaming. :|

Except it isn't going to be applied to use unless the same clues are seen in character as out of character.

So no, he did not admit to Metagaming.

 

[Dalamus Ulom]

How is knowing a servant's identity OOC, but not IC, an advantage if not through metagame? The answer is it's not. So you literally admitted to metagaming. :|

As I said before, when you assume, you make an ass out of you and me.

 

[Jean Otus]

That's why I'm confused rofl. If you got it turned around then I'd say Luis II is Ruler's identity.

Wrong again. Big libraries, big libraries, and crows' nests

 

[Xel]

Except it isn't going to be applied to use unless the same clues are seen in character as out of character.

So no, he did not admit to Metagaming.

Then it isn't an advantage :| That's the point. Knowing a servant's identity OOC literally can not be an advantage unless you metagame. Since you can't do anything without that information.

 

[Xel]

Wrong again. Big libraries, big libraries, and crows' nests

What, Matthias Corvinus?

 

[HTCOR]

Then it isn't an advantage :| That's the point. Knowing a servant's identity OOC literally can not be an advantage unless you metagame. Since you can't do anything without that information.

It's only an advantage tin the point where you can fit the puzzle pieces together using the same pieces that you are given ICly, that you were OOCly.

 

[Jean Otus]

What, Matthias Corvinus?

There we go, only took you a few tries but you got there

 

[Xel]

It's only an advantage tin the point where you can fit the puzzle pieces together using the same pieces that you are given ICly, that you were OOCly.

You'd be able to get those puzzles even if you didn't know OOC beforehand, though. So it's still not an advantage unless you're using your OOC knowledge to find clues you wouldn't normally be able to get.

 

[Xel]

There we go, only took you a few tries but you got there

You getting the sultans wrong screwed me up, so it's your fault !

 

[Godhowsae]

He was, but he's not that king, they were related though so trace your fingers up along the tree and you'll find him by the crow's nest

Sigismund I the Old.

 

[Jean Otus]

You getting the sultans wrong screwed me up, so it's your fault !

As eternal enemy of the sultans I cannot be bothered to remember who it was that invaded the country when

 

[Jean Otus]

Sigismund I the Old.

Bit late to the party it's Matthias Corvinus

 

[Xel]

As eternal enemy of the sultans I cannot be bothered to remember who it was that invaded the country when

!

 

[HTCOR]

You'd be able to get those puzzles even if you didn't know OOC beforehand, though. So it's still not an advantage unless you're using your OOC knowledge to find clues you wouldn't normally be able to get.

As stated. It isn't an advantage. And the puzzle pieces will only apply if given to the person that looks them over, and sees the two pieces together.

I've been agreeing with you on that point. So I could literally call you metagaming for knowing Assassin's identity, and your willingness to flaunt it.

 

[Dalamus Ulom]

It's only an advantage tin the point where you can fit the puzzle pieces together using the same pieces that you are given ICly, that you were OOCly.

You'd be able to get those puzzles even if you didn't know OOC beforehand, though. So it's still not an advantage unless you're using your OOC knowledge to find clues you wouldn't normally be able to get.

Correction, it's an advantage because if I am correct, then I don't want any one else to know, even if it is only OOC.

 

[Jean Otus]

!

As stated before I am the ruler of this war, therefore I am the only ruler who matters

 

[Godhowsae]

Bit late to the party it's Matthias Corvinus

Ah. I'm only skimming through the posts as I write up an IC post.

 

[Xel]

As stated. It isn't an advantage. And the puzzle pieces will only apply if given to the person that looks them over, and sees the two pieces together.

I've been agreeing with you on that point. So I could literally call you metagaming for knowing Assassin's identity, and your willingness to flaunt it.

Then if it isn't an advantage tell me who you think Caster is. Since you don't gain anything from knowing in OOC without metagaming.

Correction, it's an advantage because if I am correct, then I don't want any one else to know, even if it is only OOC.

Then PM it to me if that's your fear. There's still no reason not to tell me if you got it or not.

 

[Jean Otus]

Ah. I'm only skimming through the posts as I write up an IC post.

Well now you know, feel free to google my accomplishments and praise me for them