Slipping through the open portal, first Snowfall and then Eron spot a pair of men in lab coats that are seated nearby at computer terminals, their attention thankfully focused on the displays in front of them. You are only feet away from these two, and you have mere moments to act before they have a chance to spot you and try to raise an alarm.
Purr and Silanon What do you do?
Sherwood
While I can appreciate your looking out for the party's P.P.E. and Portal spell (those are indeed good things!), I fear one my few but strong buttons has been pushed here. I really don't like it when someone starts (I believe the term is) "power-playing" or "bunnying" (is the term "god-modding?") another's character, especially when it's the DM/Storyteller. When you inform us that Eron is taking an action Sil clearly implied Eron wasn't taking, that's... doing just that.
I don't "god-mod" players in the games I run because I feel if I take control of your non-possessed, dominated, Charmed, etc. PC, then why would you bother staying at our table? Just to watch me play YOUR character? What's the point of that? If I want to see people playing each other, I'll watch television. Right?
I mean... say in Sharseya right now, you, Luna's creator and sole Player, declare to me, "Dann, Luna stays with the party and sorts out a plan while Kaerri sneaks off." If my next phrase is, "O.K.. Kaerri and Luna go down to the giants together," then something has gone wrong. And , at least in my head, it requires immediate fixing!
Sherwood, when you "take over" Eron and inform us that he stepped through the portal right after Snowfall with no break in-between, not only do I feel like our entire plan has been disregarded, but I don't feel like my voice as a PC is... valued? Cared for? Even if it isn't my PC. And I'm sure you care. That's why this action surprises me. Plus, our entire situation has now gone sideways. We now go from Snowfall in Cloud Form quickly peeking into the room and possibly warning the party to... "Hey, you have about two moments to Roll Initiative oh and it's all because Eron stepped through too!"
He did? Do what, man?
Here's how much god-modding bugs me. In the extreme, I have cheerfully departed games when the DM repeatedly won't back down being what I see as a controlling DM. After just a few displays of this behavior, it tends to look like this (and yes, it's happened on RP Nation too):
DM: "Dannigan, your character is going to do this."
Dann: "Pardon me? It's my character. You have plenty of your own to play. My character wouldn't do this; they'd do that."
DM: "Well, you're wrong."
Dann: "Why are you doing this?
DM: "I'm the DM and I say your character is doing this."
Dann standing up and collecting his things: "Have a good day, everyone! I'm off to find the fun elsewhere." *takes my character sheet and leaves with a surprised smile*
Now, you and I are nowhere near that level of the staircase, but with you telling us what Eron is doing and not Sil, I think we're firmly on the first step. You have declared that Eron and Snowfall are now in a position neither of them wanted to be in nor made any declaration toward.
So... now what? Snowfall and I are stunned out of our minds! Time to adapt? Time to retcon? How do we fix this?
It's your game and you're the GM and I respect that, but I feel our characters should enjoy that same respect, now and in the future.
Right?