Kyuubey
Yūgen
Why would Sora be in it? |:Zuka said:
Fairy Tail: A Fandom OOC
- Thread starter Mitchs98
- Start date
Mitchs98
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡° )
Rngesus.Zuka said:
Mitchs98
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡° )
That aside I plan to have NPC judges. Lol.Zuka said:
Maki
Ten Thousand Club
Mizuki's going to have quite the entrance when Alicia arrives.
Mitchs98
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡° )
Inb4 bearhugs Alicia to ded.Kayzo said:
Maki
Ten Thousand Club
Kinda.Mitchs98 said:
Salt Lord
┬┴┬┴┤ ͜ʖ ͡°) ├┬┴┬┴
Back on~
Maki
Ten Thousand Club
My heart is racing omg.
LeSoraAmari
The Grand Herald of Tea
I personally thought that Gilad was No.1 tbh, top dog.Colt556 said:
But on another note I don't think anyone is silly enough to try Gilad xD
Colt556
Three Thousand Club
If it was up to me, knowing what I know about Fairy Tail. Gilad would be the only saint in the top 4, as the top 4 saints (granted, this was for those specific saints and not in a general sense) were regarded as so powerful they weren't even human. Even then I'm not sure I'd have Gilad in those four. Claire and Maya would be fairly low on the totem poll, basically Jura-tier when Jura first showed up. Sasuke, given what he's approved to be, I can see being mid-way up the latter, think magic games arc Jura. Wizard saints are stupidly strong in general and aren't something your normal character should be. Couple that with the fact that Jura is, quite literally, the only saint ever shown to be a member of a guild and that's even more reason why I think the guild-member saints should be fairly low ranking. Your top tier wizard saints are old, experienced, and exceptionally powerful.LeSoraAmari said:
Basically, I'm of the mind that 'real' characters shouldn't be that strong. Gilad is playing the role of Makarov, essentially. Super strong but he doesn't really do anything beyond his few cool moments, he isn't one of the main characters. I call him a plot device for a reason. But Claire, Sasuke, and Maya are actual legitimate characters and as such they should be relatively in synch with the other characters in terms of power level. I mean, it would be like having Gildarts running around with Grey, Natsu, Erza, Lucy, and Wendy. They would all be entirely useless since Gildarts alone could solve every single issue because the power gap is just that extreme.
Some power gap is fine, Erza is stronger than the rest of the group, but it isn't THAT drastic and all of them can pull through in a pinch. That's why I, personally, see Claire more in an Erza sense. Sure she might be stronger than the other fairy tail guys but not by that much, otherwise it ruins the RP for others as Claire could just win every fight by herself. Same for Maya, or Sasuke for that matter. For them to participate along side other characters they need to be comparable in strength to other characters.
TL
R non-plot device characters shouldn't be stupidly strong otherwise they overshadow everyone else.
LeSoraAmari
The Grand Herald of Tea
Yeah, that's why I didn't put Maya as one of the Four Gods of Ishgar. Purely for the fact that their strength is near unrivalled and they are regarded as inhuman. Although there is quite a power gap between her and the other mages of the guild, I didn't want to make her that strong. The guild masters would be able to fight her, even if it's with some difficulty. And Gilad would just annihilate her like Makarov did to Jose. Maya isn't indestructible. It makes sense for Gilad to be, as you've stated. Plus he's a guild master, so it makes even more sense. I think 5th is a good rank for her anyway. Plus it was Juras rank come later on in the show (and manga) so I know how far to take things with Maya. Plus he was apart of Lamia Scale, it all makes sense to me.Colt556 said:If it was up to me, knowing what I know about Fairy Tail. Gilad would be the only saint in the top 4, as the top 4 saints (granted, this was for those specific saints and not in a general sense) were regarded as so powerful they weren't even human. Even then I'm not sure I'd have Gilad in those four. Claire and Maya would be fairly low on the totem poll, basically Jura-tier when Jura first showed up. Sasuke, given what he's approved to be, I can see being mid-way up the latter, think magic games arc Jura. Wizard saints are stupidly strong in general and aren't something your normal character should be. Couple that with the fact that Jura is, quite literally, the only saint ever shown to be a member of a guild and that's even more reason why I think the guild-member saints should be fairly low ranking. Your top tier wizard saints are old, experienced, and exceptionally powerful.
Basically, I'm of the mind that 'real' characters shouldn't be that strong. Gilad is playing the role of Makarov, essentially. Super strong but he doesn't really do anything beyond his few cool moments, he isn't one of the main characters. I call him a plot device for a reason. But Claire, Sasuke, and Maya are actual legitimate characters and as such they should be relatively in synch with the other characters in terms of power level. I mean, it would be like having Gildarts running around with Grey, Natsu, Erza, Lucy, and Wendy. They would all be entirely useless since Gildarts alone could solve every single issue because the power gap is just that extreme.
Some power gap is fine, Erza is stronger than the rest of the group, but it isn't THAT drastic and all of them can pull through in a pinch. That's why I, personally, see Claire more in an Erza sense. Sure she might be stronger than the other fairy tail guys but not by that much, otherwise it ruins the RP for others as Claire could just win every fight by herself. Same for Maya, or Sasuke for that matter. For them to participate along side other characters they need to be comparable in strength to other characters.
TL
Gilad is, as you've said, a plot device. I can only see you actually using him to enhance the plot instead of anything else anyway, you wouldn't have him roaming the streets constantly xD
I like Gilad anyway, he's a cool guy with an axe.
Last edited by a moderator:
Colt556
Three Thousand Club
Gilad's there for good old Fairy Tail fashioned asspulls. "Oh, what's that? Some big bad the main team has absolutely no hope of beating? Well would you look at that, Gilad just happened to show up in the nick of time to save you!".LeSoraAmari said:
When I think of Gilad I think of the Phantom Lord arc and how Jose was entirely unstoppable up until Makarov made his appearance to finish up the conflict.
Colt556
Three Thousand Club
Man I hate making such short replies, especially given the time between posts. But goddamnit there's only so much you can do mid-conversation.
Zooks
Respawn!
I thought you mentioned in a post she was going in it O.o maybe she was just making fun of Clair thenKyuubey said:
Neferiti
Junior Member
Don't blame yourself, there truly is only so much that can be done mid-conversation *cries and hugs*Colt556 said:
Zooks
Respawn!
@Kayzo
I can't believe I basically made Valken as Gray only with Shadow Possession, which makes Millie basically Juvia.
Which also makes it hilarious finding GIFS xD
Valken right now bring protective.
Colt556
Three Thousand Club
Time for bed. Tomorrow I must enlist the girls of Fairy Tail to forcefully crossdress Mr. Seraphim over there.
Neferiti
Junior Member
Cross dress?! You- You're insane! Never you will never take him!!Colt556 said:
Zooks
Respawn!
Done and done. *Bows*Colt556 said:
Zooks
Respawn!
Now would you like PigTails, or a Ponytail.... *rubbing her hands manically*Neferiti said:
Last edited by a moderator:
Neferiti
Junior Member
Pigtai- I mean Never! You will never take him!!Zuka said:
Zooks
Respawn!
*steps away having already done the deed* Alright, now which heels and coloured bikini? >:3Neferiti said:
Neferiti
Junior Member
B- pfft I'm not falling for the same trap twice, I said never. You'll have to take me by force or something >.>Zuka said: