Sherwood
Psychie
By George, I've got it! And Princess Psychie? You helped me realize it when you mentioned Jeet Kune Do (and my realizing that C'arl isn't a thinker)!
The problem isn't the system; it's the character! C'arl can't do well the only thing he's supposed to do well - fight! Plus, while he makes for a great side character, I have my doubts that he's great long-term.
What it boils down to is the same thing it always boils down to (for me) - if I am going to play in a game, I just have to create a character I'm wild over! Anything less isn't right for the game, for you, or for me! It's like bringing old pizza to a long-running tabletop game. Just don't do it!
So what's the answer?
New personality! Somebody completely new! If I can't play my genius T'kar (I.Q. is far too low) and I can't play C'arl (who is probably O.K. in basic fights against the Invid but just about useless against foes who can take on our higher-end STORM soldiers, plus I won't roleplay Attributes my PC doesn't have), then I can create somebody in-between! Someone who's kind of smart, and can kind of fight, but he's not great at either.
Yeaaah. What if...
...there were this bear that just kept getting tossed from squad to squad to squad because nobody wanted him (he wasn't "leet" enough, he embarrassed them with his nerdiness, he couldn't "keep up with the big dogs")? What if that meek bear were indeed the science officer the group lacks (Sherwood made a great point on landing on new worlds, worlds that perhaps have been inhabited before)? Since we're all 1st level novices, what if this bear got tossed into this game (which has indeed been already set in motion) and your group got the FNB (freakin' new bear), the scientific Karbarran who loves to adventurously drive his Silverback into parts unknown?
While I don't have a name for him just yet (maybe a she?), an idea is forming in my head (always when I need to go to bed to be ready for Real Life when I wake up! Does anyone else have this problem? Ack!).
Lost artifacts from a distant race killed long ago by the Invid for their proto-protoculture? Plants and fauna of all kinds of smells, shapes, and sizes found nowhere else in all the galaxy? And a little robot (Honey) to help shine light into dark corners?
That's the kind of bear I think I'd love to play!
Too bad no squad out there would like having a walking geekfest like this for a squad member even if he can heft a flak cannon without the use of a Silverback. Who would want him, right? At least, that's what my bear thinks. Maybe your squad can find a way to change his mind?
(Now, with all this out of my head, I think I can finally go to sleep! Wish me luck and good night!)
By George, I've got it! And Princess Psychie? You helped me realize it when you mentioned Jeet Kune Do (and my realizing that C'arl isn't a thinker)!
The problem isn't the system; it's the character! C'arl can't do well the only thing he's supposed to do well - fight! Plus, while he makes for a great side character, I have my doubts that he's great long-term.
What it boils down to is the same thing it always boils down to (for me) - if I am going to play in a game, I just have to create a character I'm wild over! Anything less isn't right for the game, for you, or for me! It's like bringing old pizza to a long-running tabletop game. Just don't do it!
So what's the answer?
New personality! Somebody completely new! If I can't play my genius T'kar (I.Q. is far too low) and I can't play C'arl (who is probably O.K. in basic fights against the Invid but just about useless against foes who can take on our higher-end STORM soldiers, plus I won't roleplay Attributes my PC doesn't have), then I can create somebody in-between! Someone who's kind of smart, and can kind of fight, but he's not great at either.
Yeaaah. What if...
...there were this bear that just kept getting tossed from squad to squad to squad because nobody wanted him (he wasn't "leet" enough, he embarrassed them with his nerdiness, he couldn't "keep up with the big dogs")? What if that meek bear were indeed the science officer the group lacks (Sherwood made a great point on landing on new worlds, worlds that perhaps have been inhabited before)? Since we're all 1st level novices, what if this bear got tossed into this game (which has indeed been already set in motion) and your group got the FNB (freakin' new bear), the scientific Karbarran who loves to adventurously drive his Silverback into parts unknown?
While I don't have a name for him just yet (maybe a she?), an idea is forming in my head (always when I need to go to bed to be ready for Real Life when I wake up! Does anyone else have this problem? Ack!).
I sure don't want any "gimmees" (unearned rewards or favors) unless everyone is getting them. Even then, my new bear will very likely be into archaeology, anthropology, biology, electronics (not mechanics; that's another PC's field in here), and robotics, but instead of being a super-soldier (as your characters seem to be), he's a science-bear! He's supposed to be geeky, poor at combat, and involved in science-things most soldiers could care less about!A free 24 is a possibility that I will consider. I don't want to go ass far as the 30 you did in your game; that was your thing to do to make your game unique. We are all still early enough in the game that adding this to your sheets won't be a game breaker.
The skill bump is a good point, too. It would certainly make T'kar a skilled mechanic, even at level 1.
Lost artifacts from a distant race killed long ago by the Invid for their proto-protoculture? Plants and fauna of all kinds of smells, shapes, and sizes found nowhere else in all the galaxy? And a little robot (Honey) to help shine light into dark corners?
That's the kind of bear I think I'd love to play!
Too bad no squad out there would like having a walking geekfest like this for a squad member even if he can heft a flak cannon without the use of a Silverback. Who would want him, right? At least, that's what my bear thinks. Maybe your squad can find a way to change his mind?
(Now, with all this out of my head, I think I can finally go to sleep! Wish me luck and good night!)