Fantasy Magical Guardian Girls OOC

[DuckPrince]

why bother saving him when the rest of the gang can just follow suit, too? >:3c

evil shit XD jk jk, not trying to be mean XD

 

[Idea]

i think that kodomo should take the role of the last magical boy, since thats what they wanted in the first place, anyways. :b

id like to have my character stay the way they are.

Yeah, I was just saying if you'd prefer to take the vacant magical girl role right away or keep the current plans XD

shhhh xD
not evil, just temporarily bad! until they save him! XD

why bother saving him when the rest of the gang can just follow suit, too? >:3c

I had actually thought of doing a similar thing with my character, tbh

 

[DuckPrince]

Yeah, I was just saying if you'd prefer to take the vacant magical girl role right away or keep the current plans XD



I had actually thought of doing a similar thing with my character, tbh

as much as I love plotting due to my nature as a gemini, I think we should wait for Just Me. to come back instead of flooding her with messages to read thru

 

[Idea]

Hmmmm...nah

 

[sardinevictimsunit]

telling us that youre plotting but not telling us about the plots? dude, thats SICK.

 

[Just Me.]

Ah, apologies.

I believe the idea of having that second in command join the school and eventually becoming a good guy could work- however, this would require that the negalites as a race/group are developed into beings we can understand, that they are more than a race of chaos and destruction. That in itself would bring a new level of depth and darkness to the roleplay since we are no longer just killing the pests of the universe, we are killing creatures with just a different culture.
AKA if the negalites are like incarnations of negativity and evil then one of them turning good would be nonsensical. If they aren't then the reasons why this whole battle is happening need to be fleshed out better.

The other part of my post is that as a rule of thumb it's better to involve the stories of existing characters into the narrative rather than whipping characters from thin air. Wouldn't it work better maybe if one of the magical boys was more antagonistic and then became good for example, filling in the trope while allowing the players to have a say in that conflict? Involving character's parents, NPCs players create, stuff like that can help give the story a more airtight and involving feel.

Of course, this is all just me spitting out my opinion.

Basically my OC would be the bastard son of the second in command and one of the other kingdoms commoners so he is different as it is.

As for Negalites, think of it like the opponents of Sailor Moon or something like that.

 

[Idea]

As for Negalites, think of it like the opponents of Sailor Moon or something like that.

Admitedly as I said previously: I haven't seen Sailor Moon. From what I remember they were pure evil.

 

[sardinevictimsunit]

i dont think that one of the negalites should turn good or anything, but maybe we can interact with some at a point of the story outside of the midst of battle and have them display more, humanlike mannerisms, so to speak?

 

[sardinevictimsunit]

itd plant some BIG DOUBT into the magical girls and it sounds pretty interesting to me

 

[DuckPrince]

Just Me. sorry for swamping you XD
and I haven't watched it either. There's nothing an unknowingly trans kid hated more than sailor moon and watched naruto in Italian every morning

 

[sardinevictimsunit]

boy or girl, sailor moon is some classic shit, to be honest, and even i can appreciate the theme song. (fighting evil by moonlight, winning love by daylight, never running from a real fight)

 

[DuckPrince]

boy or girl, sailor moon is some classic shit, to be honest, and even i can appreciate the theme song. (fighting evil by moonlight, winning love by daylight, never running from a real fight)

I was more of a Lady Oscar and Naruto type kid. Or Georgie or how you call it
Sailor moon was annoying to me when I was little XD the premise of girls going neked and getting dressed again was something my 6 year old brain understood back then XDD

 

[Just Me.]

Okay I made a CS and you can decide what's what after reading it =] sorry if I didn't answer to some comments, I didn't have time to read up yet (turns out my family had to go to some Christmas dinner and just stopped by to give me a present hehe) should I post my CS here?

P.S.: in sailor moon a bad guy turned good too (well but he died shortly after...)

 

[DuckPrince]

Okay I made a CS and you can decide what's what after reading it =] sorry if I didn't answer to some comments, I didn't have time to read up yet (turns out my family had to go to some Christmas dinner and just stopped by to give me a present hehe) should I post my CS here?

P.S.: in sailor moon a bad guy turned good too (well but he died shortly after...)

would it be a decent plot point for Akio to be influenced by evil at some point and being saved by the girls(could be like a lesson to them or something).

 

[Idea]

ever running from a real fight

Nostalgia Critic: *plays clip of main character running away from a real fight*

 

[Idea]

Okay I made a CS and you can decide what's what after reading it =] sorry if I didn't answer to some comments, I didn't have time to read up yet (turns out my family had to go to some Christmas dinner and just stopped by to give me a present hehe) should I post my CS here?

P.S.: in sailor moon a bad guy turned good too (well but he died shortly after...)

Don't worry take your time. Most of it was banter anyway

 

[Just Me.]

would it be a decent plot point for Akio to be influenced by evil at some point and being saved by the girls(could be like a lesson to them or something).

Sure, it would make for an interesting read. So yes I am good with it.

 

[sardinevictimsunit]

to be honest, playing on team evil does sound pretty fun, and kiyoko is already on true neutral as far as alignments are concerned. it wouldnt be too hard for her to lean towards evil gang >:3

 

[sardinevictimsunit]

if im allowed to roll with her original story, with her being the pampered daughter of a high-ranking yakuza member who she doesnt really like all that much, itd be that much better tbh

 

[Idea]

(Idea idea thought could have been a real kicker later, everyone else doing it now - the going evil one)

 

[sardinevictimsunit]

i was evil before it was cool >:b

 

[Idea]

I thought it yesterday- ironically during Christmas eve mass

 

[Idea]

I was going to propose by PM (though at this point might as well do it here) , a kind of "miasma" concept to Just Me. - where like a magical being's troubles could manifest in a pseudo-negallite form for a magical girl if they got too out of hand.

 

[sardinevictimsunit]

inb4 rp becomes puella magi madoka magica

 

[Idea]

I'll keep the other idea I had in mind a secret...maybe...