Fandom Fate/Bad Joke OOC

[Mion]

What about a mentally ill person? Or a person born with certain lack of traits compared to a regular human? Would they still be considered humans?

Those are anomalies that prove the rule. But all properly functioning humans have it.

 

[Xel]

Caster's wish requires to him to live to a certain duration.

And how long is that duration?

 

[QuirkyAngel]

And how long is that duration?

Until his wish is accomplished

I will spoil nothing more in the ooc.

 

[Xel]

Until his wish is accomplished

I will spoil nothing more in the ooc.

Seems like a hassle. Best to just murder him.

 

[QuirkyAngel]

Seems like a hassle. Best to just murder him.

My~Saber's a simple one^^

 

[Xel]

My~Saber's a simple one^^

Maybe if the other servants put up a good showing and Saber believes she could use the help. But currently she's of the firm belief that no servant in the war can challenge her and thus has no need for allies who would likely backstab her anyways.

 

[QuirkyAngel]

Maybe if the other servants put up a good showing and Saber believes she could use the help. But currently she's of the firm belief that no servant in the war can challenge her and thus has no need for allies who would likely backstab her anyways.

Hmm, I see. I wish her the best then.

I'm just waiting to see whether or not Eli will punch Caster^^

 

[Girouette]

WASUP MY HOMIES, Y'ALL READY FOR SOME BOMB-ASS DOPE ZERKER POSTS? PREP THEM COOKIES FOR SOME FLIPPIN AWESOME DESCRIPTIONS OF A MENTALLY ILL LADY WITH SUPERPOWERS. YAAAAAA!

 

[Girouette]

Please forgive me in advance for those two sentences.

 

[Xel]

Fuckin Don. Go eat your burgs.

Also, chaotic evil Saber when?

 

[Girouette]

When we get Zerker Alter


(Image credit to Bandit-Kun)

 

[QuirkyAngel]

*whispers* I think the normal Servants are enough. No need to bring in their alters.

 

[Girouette]

*whispers* I think the normal Servants are enough. No need to bring in their alters.

That's what the mud in the shop is for, dummy

 

[QuirkyAngel]

That's what the mud in the shop is for, dummy

I don't want it...I want the toy wand....

 

[Girouette]

I don't want it...I want the toy wand....

Don't do it. It will turn u into a magical girl.

 

[QuirkyAngel]

Don't do it. It will turn u into a magical girl.

...I want to see Eli as a magical girl

 

[Xel]

Mud for everyone, corrupt all the servants.

 

[The One Eyed Bandit]

When they aren't your civilians? Sure. Hell. Even in modern times that's still the way it is. Civilian casualties are always acceptable if it means attaining victory. That's one thing that has never change in the passing of time. No military leader saw a path to victory and refused to take it due to some civilian casualties.



It's just pragmatic logic, not good or evil. If killing someone is beneficial, people do it. If killing them is detrimental, they don't do it. Good and evil has nothing to do with it. Saber wont go out of her way to kill people, but a few civilian casualties is a small price to pay for winning the war.

Your pragmatism in this sense is inherently evil. Throwing away the lives of others for your own benefit, just because it is beneficial for you and the quickest road to success. That is objectively evil. You can argue they are subjective terms but that is absolutely incorrect. Language is a tool through which we can make descriptive observations on the normative ethics.

The subjectivness of good and evil would be more of a linguistic argument than a philosophical one. Sure they have been used to manipulate and control people but that is because language is a man made tool. Language is subjective. Ethics are not.

Then let's fulfill Caster's wish and kill him.



Except there's nothing to suggest humanity has some shared root ethics. As seen by all the immensely diverse cultures throughout history. What one culture deemed good, another culture didn't. If humanity had some innate inbuilt moral code every society would share the same ethics and concepts of good and evil, yet they don't. The only common thread is simple animalistic pragmatism. There's no biological function that tells humans what is good and what is evil. It's shaped by our circumstances, our experiences, our beliefs, and the world around us. It's entirely subjective, invented as a means to foster cooperation since cooperation is in a society's best interest. It always comes back to cold hard pragmatism, not some abstract concept such as good or evil. If it benefited society to mass murder people you can bet we'd do it in a heartbeat. Because humans have the morality they assign to themselves. We're no different than any other animal species, we are not genetically programmed with a code of conduct like you seem to believe. We invented the code of conduct to make our lives easier.

But oh wait... that's what normative ethics are.

​

what the fuck happened while i was sleeping

 

[QuirkyAngel]

A deep, meaningful discussion about Good and Evil.

 

[Iskandar]

A deep, meaningful discussion about Good and Evil.

"Deep" "Meaningful." Yes Yes.

 

[Girouette]

Technically speaking, since this IS Fate we're talking about, Humanity DOES Have a collective will that dictates the value of good and evil actions, soooooooooooo.

Yep.

Anyway, anyone see any good movies lately?

 

[Iskandar]

Technically speaking, since this IS Fate we're talking about, Humanity DOES Have a collective will that dictates the value of good and evil actions, soooooooooooo.

Yep.

Anyway, anyone see any good movies lately?

Black Panther was decent.

I want to see Isle of Dogs sooooo badly

 

[Lucem]

Lucem
The One Eyed Bandit

BABY DAN DAN
Gridman will be AotY, Franxx and VEG BTFO eternally by Greenriver.​

It looks better than I expected. I was afraid of another CG disaster.

...I want to see Eli as a magical girl

Caster would probably be genderbent against his will if Eli caught him trying to put him in a magical girl outfit.

 

[The One Eyed Bandit]

Caster would probably be genderbent against his will if Eli caught him trying to put him in a magical girl outfit.

Not if the transformation sequence is fast enough.

 

[Xel]

Caster turns Eli into a magical girl. In retaliation Eli genderbends Caster. MORE GIRLS FOR THE WAIFU WARS!