PatriasLover
Vive la Republique!
i dont think we aught to tell him, as our theory is only a theory. we don't have enough evidence, and it would be cruel to break him.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
i dont think we aught to tell him, as our theory is only a theory. we don't have enough evidence, and it would be cruel to break him.
Honestly, the evidence does kind of point to this conclusion... However, I'm leaning towards not telling Elias, too. Usually honesty is the best policy, but what does it accomplish here? It's not like it changes what happened, it's unlikely that Elias will lose control of his powers like that again since he's old enough to know what he's doing now, and if knowing this about him doesn't change anything in our relationship with him, then why even bring it up?
I'm open to having my mind changed if someone has an argument for why we should tell Elias, but for now, I'm voting to not tell him.
I often like being a little contrarian at times like this, but yeah, there's really no reason we should tell him at this point in time. The only way I could see this causing a problem down the line is if someone else puts two and two together and we have to reveal we knew and didn't say anything, but even should such a scenario come, I think "we didn't want to pointlessly accuse you and hurt your feelings" is a decent enough reason, though a person in that emotional state probably wouldn't listen regardless of the reason.
I vote no as well.
I definitely think that telling him now will make him hate himself more, and that's definitely not what we want. Keeping closed lips for the time being is probably for the best, since I know that if I heard that, I would begin freaking out and quite possibly begin to lose parts of my sanity, even with a lover there. Best to not tell him and find the best moment later on. We do need to tell him, but I'm thinking that during an intimate moment, when he is more likely to listen and understand and HOPEFULLY, not have a mental breakdown. Maybe in the near future when there is a beautiful sunset, and our eyes are locked, and we slowly lean in to kiss...
Let's... Not tell Elias... At least... Not yet... Unanimously... |
I definitely think that telling him now will make him hate himself more, and that's definitely not what we want. Keeping closed lips for the time being is probably for the best, since I know that if I heard that, I would begin freaking out and quite possibly begin to lose parts of my sanity, even with a lover there. Best to not tell him and find the best moment later on. We do need to tell him, but I'm thinking that during an intimate moment, when he is more likely to listen and understand and HOPEFULLY, not have a mental breakdown. Maybe in the near future when there is a beautiful sunset, and our eyes are locked, and we slowly lean in to kiss...
The only way I could see this causing a problem down the line is if someone else puts two and two together and we have to reveal we knew and didn't say anything, but even should such a scenario come, I think "we didn't want to pointlessly accuse you and hurt your feelings" is a decent enough reason, though a person in that emotional state probably wouldn't listen regardless of the reason.
Can’t fully agree on that speech about change, but that’s a subject for another time. I also can’t seem to remember Cora’s deal so I’m gonna do a bit of a shot in the dark here, and vote for us to tell her to stay. Feel free to convince me otherwise though.
Oh dear... While I'm sure that Cora would be more than capable here, she does have a very important obligation to the queen due to the child. It would probably be best to say that she can't come. But how to phrase it? Perhaps we could say that the queen would feel uneasy without Cora? Or am I overthinking too much?
I also think that it's probably best if Cora stays in Auran. Correct me if I'm mixing people up here, but not only is there the matter of Hellie's pregnancy, but also Cora has a young child herself, doesn't she? I'm not sure if bringing Synne here (or possibly worse, separating him from both his parents by leaving him in Auran) is such a good idea, and Clif would understand that, wouldn't he?
Tell him Cora should stay in Auran unanimously... |
I think we should suggest it. There is no harm in going to visit Clif's father, and it seems to be somewhat along the way, too, so we shouldn't lose too much time. Also, maybe he knows if someone passed through the area recently (though hopefully not with the Ruins as their goal...)? In the best case, we can deliver a message from Clif (if he wants us to) and find our next crest-bearer sooner.
Well, other than being in Sagemarch, it's not like we got a real clue where the crestbearer might be. So we might as well suggest a visit, and try to gleam some info there.
I absolutely think we should visit Clif's father. What I'm really worried about is what we are going to do if the 6th crestbearer is in the ruins. I'm honestly a bit worried that Sia is going to try and kill them. And that would be really bad. So if they are in the Ruins, that's going to be a huge problem. Also, why isn't the compass moving anymore? Shouldn't the compass be pointing at least slightly towards the forest, or moving slightly? What if the person in the forest is... Dead?
Visit Clif's Dad unanimously! |
Why isn't the compass moving anymore? Shouldn't the compass be pointing at least slightly towards the forest, or moving slightly? What if the person in the forest is... Dead?
What I'm really worried about is what we are going to do if the 6th crestbearer is in the ruins. I'm honestly a bit worried that Sia is going to try and kill them. And that would be really bad.
Good point!Rosie doesn’t know this, but from the other segment we are aware of the fact something pretty nasty can happen to Rose if she completes her quest… In which case, the tomb may have a clue into that, and to what exactly happens during the event, and if that’s the case, it might save Rose’s life.
Good point!
But while I'm sure Sia would strictly be the best when it comes to information about the Tomb, isn't she going to fly into a rage again if we mention it (and thus remind her somebody might be there without the proper authority)? I don't know how helpful it would be to ask her at the moment.
Kai and Xander both seemed to know a thing or two, too, so I'll second asking Papa (so we don't end up with a three-way tie on this decision). And maybe we can even work the book into our questions as well.
I'm thinking we talk to Papa. He had that book we couldn't read, so maybe there's something in there that could tell us about the First emperor. Plus, he has all that Papa wisdom. He has to know somoething.
Rosie doesn’t know this, but from the other segment we are aware of the fact something pretty nasty can happen to Rose if she completes her quest… In which case, the tomb may have a clue into that, and to what exactly happens during the event, and if that’s the case, it might save Rose’s life.
Just some food for thought for now.
As for clues… Sia is the one we’ve spent least amount of time with, but she’s definitely the type to look into and think about things before jumping into a situation and on a regular basis. I think there’s a lot she knows we haven’t talked to her enough to uncover yet, so she might know something that will give clarity to this situation.
Good point!
But while I'm sure Sia would strictly be the best when it comes to information about the Tomb, isn't she going to fly into a rage again if we mention it (and thus remind her somebody might be there without the proper authority)? I don't know how helpful it would be to ask her at the moment.
Kai and Xander both seemed to know a thing or two, too, so I'll second asking Papa (so we don't end up with a three-way tie on this decision). And maybe we can even work the book into our questions as well.
To be fair, while she did fly into a rage earlier, she was caught by surprise. She might be more calm and have had time to think about it more rationally by now.
Papa, 2 to 1! |
My brain is whirring right now, but aside from the real question, does the book tell us what all the crestbearers powers are? That would be useful to know, because depending on the power, that could explain why the compass needle isn't moving at all.
(Hi, nice to see you!)*waves at Felis *
Tell them... what exactly? I don't think we've actually come up with any theories beyond what either of them could've thought of themselves, and even then those theories aren't super solid.
That being said... being stuck unmoving... in the place where we're told there's only a statue.
Crazy theory time: I'm 99% sure I'm wrong about this, but just in case, it's almost giving the impression the last crestbearer is either the first emperor or someone who was stuck with some kind of magic/trap/curse and turned into a statue as well.
Side note, I would love to have an entry from the other perspective soon. Anyone else?
As for my vote, I'll say no, can't think of anything worth telling them yet unless I missed some detail Rose knows and they don't.
My brain is whirring right now, but aside from the real question, does the book tell us what all the crestbearers powers are? That would be useful to know, because depending on the power, that could explain why the compass needle isn't moving at all.
But the big problem with telling them these theories is that it's going ono the assumption that they are still in the ruins area. And I don't exactly want to look like a fool in front of them if they happen to be just outside of the ruins or such. Even then, what if they were forced there by locals as a punishment of some kind and are trapped there somehow? I still feel uneasy about telling or not, so I think I'll abstain from this vote unless necessary.
TELL THEM! [Y] / N
Fair is fair. My guess is that, barring the possibility that the person is a fantastic cosplayer who took the form of a statue of the First Emperor and then actually being turned to stone, that this is in fact the First Emperor. Idea may be onto something.
*waves at Felis *.
I think staying silent may make us look like we know more than we do, and then maybe somewhere down the road they rely on us knowing something we actually don't.
I'd say let's share our theories, especially since I also think Idea has a good point. I don't think it's a problem that we don't have anything solid yet. It's not too crazy to say that it's an awful coincidence that the compass needle is quite literally still as a statue and the petrified Emperor is in the Ruins... And even if they don't take it seriously, at least we'll have avoided some miscommunication, right?
(Hi, nice to see you!)
Tell them what you think! |
Crazy theory time: I'm 99% sure I'm wrong about this, but just in case, it's almost giving the impression the last crestbearer is either the first emperor or someone who was stuck with some kind of magic/trap/curse and turned into a statue as well.
I think staying silent may make us look like we know more than we do, and then maybe somewhere down the road they rely on us knowing something we actually don't.
I'd say let's share our theories, especially since I also think Idea has a good point. I don't think it's a problem that we don't have anything solid yet. It's not too crazy to say that it's an awful coincidence that the compass needle is quite literally still as a statue and the petrified Emperor is in the Ruins... And even if they don't take it seriously, at least we'll have avoided some miscommunication, right?
Crazy theory time: I'm 99% sure I'm wrong about this, but just in case, it's almost giving the impression the last crestbearer is either the first emperor or someone who was stuck with some kind of magic/trap/curse and turned into a statue as well.