OverconfidentMagi
Laugh Like You've Won Always
If they're learning everything in the badlands, what's the point of the 5 years at the monastery?Yes. During which time they learn their soul name. I believe I put this somewhere, but the whole point of the voyage is to get to the badlands, meditate or whatever to learn your soul name, and then utilize it as a team to destroy one of the giant beasts of the badlands. And anyone who survives both those halves becomes a free manifestor
Wouldn't it make more sense for the monastery to teach them to figure out their soul name, and then the final test to be using their newly awoken weapon (and the introspective knowledge that comes with knowing their own name) to accomplish something impossible (killing the beast)?
It just seems like if they could already manifest their weapon before the monastery, and then they don't actually reach the next level until after leaving the monastery, then actually going to the monastery is more of a handicap than if they didn't attend and just kept throwing themselves into difficult situations out in the wider world.