Lady Gabrienna Fromm

Elle Joyner

Fracturer of Fairytales
This character is for the RP https://www.rpnation.com/threads/chivalry-a-pilgrimage.89503/] Chivalry: The Pilgrimage[/url]. Feedback is welcome, but please remain constructive! :)


~ Lady Brien Fromm ~







  • The Eastern Fire
    c9c476e0210dc6edc757aca15e565ae2.jpg









    Order:


    Vinoviloc





    Name:


    Gabrienna Anleigh Fromm



    Gender: Female



    Age:


    Twenty-four




 
Greetings, good-Fellow Joyner! My, I really need to stop addressing you with that abhorrantly clunky nickname :P Nevertheless, I'm not here to poke fun at my own critiquing voice, I'm here to, y'know, actually critique! So, without further ado, into the review!


The first thing I must proclaim is the brilliant graphology of your form. Everything is beautifully set out, with lots of nice little pictures, nice big pictures, columns and segregated sections. Clearly a lot of work has gone into making this form presentable and neat, and it really pays off. Another thing that I especially love about this form is your general language choice. I love how the entire form is written in a way that reflects the period and context of the RP the character is involved in; it really helps to bring readers into the world. 'course, I am yet unacquianted with you normal writing, so you might just write like this anyway, but nevertheless, it's a nice touch xD Grammatically, you are almost faultless, though there are a few instances of unneccesary commas perhaps spurred on by this writing voice. They are sparce and harmless, but seeing as we're on the subject of critique, I thought I might as well point them out.


The character herself is interesting and decently developed, which is probably exactly the right amount of detail you want to start an RP with. It addresses everything you would want it to address without divulging into gratuitus amounts of unneccesary factoids. My favourite bit in particular is the appearance section! It's quite easy when you've found a good picture to just be lazy and put 'she looks like the picture duh lol', but your description is detailed and beautiful, artistic and relevant at the same time, which is really nice! Her personality seems realistic given her upbringing. I would however have liked to have seen a little more in it though. For example, you mention she has a soft spot for children due to the freedom she sees exhibited in them. This could have made an interesting part of her internal character; a character so stoic, yet beneath all that, perhaps even unwittingly, a character who desires some of this freedom. Nevertheless, all the detail you do put is neat and interesting and good.


One of the only things this form suffers from is a lack of context. Obviously this was not a problem on the RP thread itself, but as a seperate item, it's a little hard to truly grasp the world this character lives in without context. This could be remedied with a few little lines, things like just adding in a single sentence to the sections about the different provinces explaining roughly what they're like. Another things that surprises me is, given how much it is given reference across the form, what little explicit description is given to her upbringing in the background. This is perhaps due to the form you undertook for it; the first person is definitely cool, but it does mean that knowledge of her background is left to inference. I must admit, it did take me a few flicks past to truly get that she was brought up strictly by mother and father in conflicting manners, and whilst, like I said, the first person background is cool, for the purpose of data that character forms usually want, it might have been better to explain these things outright.



Ratings:



Style/Design: :5/5:Beautifully organised, written and laid out.



Appearance: :5/5:Detailed beautifully and relevantly.



Personality: :3/5:Realistic and understandable, however, lacks any standout traits in comparison to characters of a similar disposition.



Background::4/5:Really interestingly written, but lacking in specific moments that explain your characters personality, and also not too explicit in parts.



Extras::4/5:Sensible amounts of relevant detail without being pushy or unneccesary.



Overall::4/5:



I hope this is helpful!
:D


 
Review for Lady Gabrienna

@Elle Joyner

Details: :5/5:


Appearance: :5/5:


Traits: :4/5:


Back Story: :3/5:


Overall: :4/5:


Additional Notes:





This character sheet is very well done and beautifully formatted! I am reminded of my own character whenever I think of Lady Gabrienna. Have you met my girl, Gwendalin, yet? I think Gabrienna and Gwendalin would hit it off pretty well. Perhaps we should set them up for coffee one of these days. ( ;) )


Though I would have never written them the way you did, your descriptions for you character work really wonderfully. In a way they seem to describe her attributes and imperfections without really having to state the fact. Your descriptions speak for themselves.


We understand which personality traits she possesses, but we do not get to see which instances where these personalities are portrayed. Nor do we get to see where these personality traits actually come from, even in the back story. We are also left asking why she was sent to the neighboring land to receive training. Was it a custom? Did her parents send her? Was it out of rebellion? For me, some of the pre-character development is missing for Gabrienna.


I believe some of my confusion may come from the fact that his CS is very roleplay associated, which is okay! But, if you ever wanted to use her in the future for other roleplays, I would suggest focusing your edits on globalizing this character. (^.^)


Cheers!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top