Author's Note
This will be an Alternate Universe short story of Elfen Lied, the central premise of which asks the question: "What if Lucy/Kaede's escape was not a premeditated effort by Professor Kakuzawa, and she never reunited with Kouta?"
Please not that this is officially a trigger warning. The original Elfen Lied is a very dark and violent manga/anime which features many sensitive topics including child abuse, gory murders, suggestions of rape/pedophelia, and more.
This written work will back off significantly from the extremity of the issues as presented in the source material. However, I realize that doing so may not be enough to prevent it from still being triggering at times to some readers.
Please proceed at your own discretion.
Here's a summary for context of the lore, and some of the events which come before the short story begins:
The Diclonius are mutated humans resulting from a virus whose origins can be traced to the protagonist's (Lucy's) mother. They have vestigial horns on their heads, unusually bright red or pink tones in their hair, and have telekinetic abilities using 'arms' called Vectors. These arms vibrate at varying frequencies depending on the user's intention and are versatile enough to both harmlessly interact with objects in the world, tear human bodies limb from limb with little effort, and even deflect bullets making the Diclonii extremely dangerous if ever forced into defensive or combative situations.
Lucy, Queen of the Diclonius, was born to a normal human mother who was the true progenitor of the Diclonius race, and believed to be Patient 0 of the Diclonius Virus. Lucy was raised to believe that both her parents abandoned her to die as an infant. However, it was only her father who hated and tried to dispose of her. Lucy's mother spent the rest of her life searching for Lucy which, unfortunately, led her to being discovered and captured by Chief Kakuzawa of the Diclonius Research Institute once he learned of her ability to birth non-sterile Diclonius like Lucy. Her mother never reunited with Lucy as she took her own life after being forced to bear a Diclonius son to Chief Kakuzawa.
Lucy was neglected and largely ignored by the adults of her orphanage. But it was the horrible mistreatment and torment she received from the other children, who nicknamed her the 'Ox' thanks to the horns on her head, which drove her further and further into her hatred of humanity. She found and befriended a puppy who was later killed by the abusive children which caused Lucy to lash out with her Vectors for the first time painting the room red with their blood and littering it with the remains of their bodies. This traumatic event drove Lucy into an emotional breakdown before she ultimately ran away from the orphanage.
She later made a friend in a boy named Kouta whom she quickly fell in love with. Asking him to the upcoming festival she was dismayed to learn he was going with his cousin whom he said was a boy. She decided to go anyway in hopes of seeing and joining Kouta and his cousin, but found out that his cousin was, in fact, a girl. Feeling betrayed, and overwhelmed by the dense crowds and noise around her, she gave in to a mysterious voice inside her telling her if she didn't kill she would have no further reason left to live. She began a merciless killing spree of the festival goers before setting her sights on Kouta and his family as they departed. After killing his father and sister she promised to go after his cousin before Kouta tackled her to the ground and demanded she stopped killing. This reaction forced Lucy to realize that she was the reason the two of them could not be together now.
Following this event Lucy spent the next five years stealth killing the citizenry of Kamakura by using her Vectors to trigger heart attacks in some, and infecting young males with the Diclonius virus. Eventually the trail led authorities and the Diclonius Research Institute to put two and two together as they realized the rise in Diclonius birth rates ran parallel to the mysterious deaths which otherwise would normally be deemed as natural causes, and this eventually led to her capture by a man named Kurama. The reason for her capture was due to the only other friend she'd ever made, Aiko Takada, stepping in front of bullets to protect Lucy when they came for her. In exchange for Aiko receiving immediate medical treatment Lucy surrendered to Kurama. She later learned that Aiko had died of her wounds, and Kurama pushed the notion that it could have been avoided if Lucy had surrendered in the first place since humans only wanted to co-exist with them. Lucy refuted this claim and promised Kurama that he alone would live to suffer in the same way she did as she tore his world apart around him.
Lucy has spent the last three years in the Institute. Her body is strapped to a central metal pillar in the center of her chamber and wrapped in thick bindings similar to a straight jacket. She's also been forced to wear a special helmet in hopes that it would limit her Vector's effectiveness (it did/does not). With Vectors believed to be only 2 meters in length (6 and 1/2 feet), a cage was erected around the outer perimeter of her reach to protect any Staff who had to enter the room from her murderous intentions. Her violent nature prompted them to automate her feeding in order to keep Staff safe from her, as well as not to give her any chance to use the trays her food sat on as projectile weapons to kill them at range as she'd done in the past.
And so we come to the present day.
Lucy remains strapped to that pillar in the center of the room with no light, no activity, and no companionship. She is truly alone, and presumes that she will be forever in this hellish place. That is, until...
Part 1: The Meeting
Knock, knock.
Lucy's head lifted but an inch as the intercom crackled to life.
"Lucy? Can you hear me?"
It was a male voice. Youthful and bright with an energy to it she hadn't heard in the other Staff who'd come into the room before. Probably another dumb newbie who thought she wasn't as dangerous as they claimed.
"Lucy?"
She lowered her head, but was surprised to hear him chuckle over the intercom.
"It's okay if you don't want to talk. I just wanted to let you know I'm coming in, okay? I'll be there in just a sec."
The intercom croaked and died before the sound of the heavy metal doors of her chamber opened, followed by the sound of footsteps approaching the cage.
"Hi Lucy. I'm Takeshi. Takeshi Shirahama. I'm going to be your new caretaker starting today."
Once again she lifted her head about an inch, seeing him through the VR-like screen inside the helmet as it had no actual holes for her eyes to see through normally. This was an intentional design in an effort to limit her vision and throw off her depth perception.
He was young. But not overly so. Probably her age. Maybe a bit older. He had a nice face. Clean shaven with no marks. Black hair which was kept short and spiky. The only thing she couldn't really make out was the color of his eyes. They were hard enough to see through the screen. But the dim lighting wasn't helping either.
"I'm sure there's at least a small part of you wondering why someone would be your caretaker after they went through the trouble of automating your feeding and all that, right?"
She lowered her head.
"Well, I volunteered. It's nice to meet you."
Volunteered? He was either insane, stupid, or both. Surely he knew what she'd done to the others and why she was in a big empty cage like this?
"I know it probably sounds like a stupid thing to do. But I don't think it is."
... He was definitely stupid.
"You know, Lucy. They call you 'Diclonius.' But to I can't say that I see the difference between you and a normal girl your age."
Was he serious?
"You look human to me. Horns or no. Everyone's different in some way. That's part of the beauty of what it means to be human. You know?"
Human. If that word meant anything, it meant 'evil.'
"Don't call me that."
Her voice came out as little more than a muffled, hoarse whisper through the helmet.
"Hm? Oh, sorry. One moment. I have to turn on your helmet's microphone... Uh... One sec."
Was he serious?
He brought out a cell phone and frantically tapped its screen before finding what he was looking for.
"There we go. What was that, Lucy?"
"... I said, 'don't call me that.'"
"Call you what?"
"Human."
"Are you not?"
"I'm a Diclonius. And you humans are the reason that me and the other Diclonius kill like we do. We wanted to live in this world normally. But you hate us, and you're afraid of us. If you can't destroy us then you do this to us." She lifted her head and turned it, indicating the cage.
"If this is what it means to be human, I don't want it. I'd prefer to kill you and take my place in this world for myself." She growled.
Takeshi's face dropped, as did his voice which became much softer and less energetic.
"... You're right."
She blinked.
"Humans can be cruel, hateful, and destructive creatures. Many of us give in to our inner demons and choose violence and war over peace. And instead of accepting our differences, many of us instead push vilify each other and say awful things to try and justify when hateful words or actions are taken against others. It's honestly disgusting."
She couldn't argue. The Diclonius were either killed or imprisoned by humans at birth and given no chance to just live their lives. And it was all the fault of 'humanity.' If anything, he was just proving her point.
"If you know the evil of humanity, then why are you standing there trying to act nice?"
He lifted his head and tried to smile, though it didn't reach his eyes.
"I guess I'm just one of those weirdos who wants to be different, Lucy. When I came to work here I thought I was going to be an intern for a Children With Special Needs Development program. They didn't tell me that the children here were Diclonius, or that they have Vectors, or that they experiment on you all in vicious and cruel ways."
"Then why are you still here?"
"No choice." He chuckled.
No choice? Who was he trying to fool? These humans always had a choice. And the always made the wrong one.
"They wouldn't let me leave because by the time I asked to, I'd seen too much of the operation. After all, they have a reputation to protect back home. So, even though I reject what they're doing morally and don't want to participate in it, my only choices are to either do my job or sleep with the fishes. They even took me to the docks and threw me into the ocean at gunpoint as an example of how easy it would be to just drop my services and let me find my way back home across hundreds of miles of open water."
"This just proves my point more."
"To some degree, yes. I like to believe there are more people like me out there who know this is wrong and would never do anything like this to others. And I think, on some level, you do too. After all, I was briefed on the details of your capture. You'd made a friend who was killed by Kurama and his men, right? So you've seen the goodness in humanity at least once."
No reply.
"There are a lot more people like that girl out there, Lucy. People who would see you and think you're beautiful, and worth their time to interact with like anyone else. People who would be your friends, and show you respect and kindness without any thought of compensation. Humanity is full of good people trying to do the right thing. But for every good person out there, there's probably at least one bad one who don't care to do the right thing. And, unfortunately, they're usually the first to take action. And by the time we come around and say they're wrong they've already got a stranglehold on the issue and have brought more to their side than we can fight back against. And it's pretty much like that no matter where in the world you go."
His thinking was pathetic.
"If there were more like her than like here in this place, I wouldn't be here right now. And the Diclonius wouldn't be the subject of your experiments and cruelty. Honestly, I prefer just killing you and carving out a place in this world for myself and my Diclonius brethren. And once I get out of here I'll be able to do just that."
"Maybe this is me being dumb, but I honestly don't think you'll kill me, Lucy."
"Why not?"
"I think on some level or another all Diclonius want to live a normal life knowing kindness, respect, and all of the other good behaviors that we humans take for granted amongst ourselves."
"What makes you think that?"
"Well, you're not the only Diclonius I'm the caretaker of. Granted, the others are younger than you. Still children, for the most part. The oldest is fourteen. But they're learning to trust me. The youngest even let me pat her on the head the other day after finishing the meal I prepped for her."
"You think That's a show of trust?"
"I do, Lucy. She used to flinch when I reached out to her. But she doesn't anymore."
"That doesn't mean she trusts you."
"Perhaps not yet. But it's a step in the right direction. They're learning what kindness is, little by little. And I'm hoping to be able to help you remember what kindness is too, Lucy. You deserve it."
... 'You deserve it.' After the things he obviously knew she'd done, he feels she deserves kindness? He truly was stupid. And insane. Nobody could ever think that she deserved kindness after all the mass murder she'd committed.
"I'll be back later with a proper meal for you. I'm not a fan of that slop they feed you through the automated system."
"Don't bother. I'll just kill you once the tray is close enough."
He chuckled.
"I see. Then I guess you don't want me to take off that helmet so you can eat properly?"
The helmet. They were dumb enough to think it could weaken her Vectors. But it was uncomfortable. And she'd never figured out how to remove the damn thing. It was resistant to her Vectors when she tired to destroy it, for some reason. Was that the true purpose of it? That it could resist and would force her to see the world through a distorted lens so she had a harder time killing than normal? She hadn't given it all that much thought before this. But if he could remove it... He'd be that much easier to kill once she could see properly.
"Fine. But like I said, don't be surprised when I kill you once the helmet's off."
"Not a problem, Lucy. I'll see you later."
With that he turned and left the room, leaving Lucy with the only companion she'd known for the last three years... Silence.
Hours passed. But it was nothing new. They promised regular feeding but would routinely make excuses for the automated feeder to "break down" so she'd go sometimes days without any food. Curiously the water always worked. Mechanical failures were rather selective in this place. And-
Creak.
The big metal doors opened.
"Good evening, Lucy. I brought dinner, as promised."
He carried a tray with quite a lot of food on it and stopped right outside the cage.
"I got a bit carried away and made too much. So, I hope you're hungry. If not I can help you finish whatever you can't eat. No sense wasting good food, you know?"
"Remember what I told you earlier, human."
"I remember. You said I shouldn't be surprised if you kill me when the helmet comes off."
"'When' I kill you."
"Ah, of course. My mistake."
No mistake. He was trying to save himself like the others did. They'd all begged for their lives in some way, even if it was just in their eyes.
Anyway, I thought we'd talk a bit before I give you your meal, if that's okay?"
And there it was. The promise of feeding, but conditionally. Always conditionally.
"What do you want now?"
"I'd like to do a trust exercise with you, Lucy."
"You can't be serious."
"I am. I did this with the other Diclonius as well. All I'd like to do is walk into the cage and be allowed to stand there for ten seconds without getting mangled. Will you allow me to?"
"Fine. Get it over with."
If he was actually going to take this blasted helmet off it'd be worth humoring him for ten measly seconds.
"You got it."
He opened the cage and walked inside. But what was strange to Lucy was that he was smiling at her. And not in a snarky or condescending way. He was smiling like... No. She shouldn't think about that. It was a long time ago. This was different. Completely different.
"There we go. Thanks, Lucy."
That went by faster than expected. Perhaps the memories had distorted her perception of time?
"So, that's it?"
"That was it!"
"And what purpose did that serve?"
... Wait. Why did she care to know?
"Just a little trust exercise. I trusted you not to kill me for the ten seconds I was allowed into the cage. And you didn't kill me. So, as far as I'm concerned, my trust in you was validated."
"And what am I supposed to get out of it?"
"Dinner, and the removal of your helmet, of course." He chuckled.
He picked up the dinner tray and walked inside the cage again.
Kill him.
The voice. It was back. She hadn't heard it in quite a long time while sitting in silence in this room. But now that she wasn't alone it had come back, like before.
Kill him, now. He's just toying with you like the others did. And he'll betray and hurt you just like the others did.
"I know." She muttered.
"Hm? Did you say something, Lucy?"
She hadn't even realized he was already in front of her and reaching up towards the helmet.
"Just give me one sec. This stupid thing is tricky since I can't see the mechanism."
He was so close. His face was so close. She could rip him in half, decapitate him, or whatever else she wanted right here, right now. He truly was the epitome of what it meant for a human to be stupid, wasn't he? And the moment that helmet came off...
"Hm... I can't feel the mechanism. I wonder if your helmet's modified compared to the others?"
Excuses.
"Mind turning your head a bit? I think it'll help if I can see it."
Lucy slowly turned her head, but kept him in the peripheral view of the screen inside her helmet.
"Hmmmm... Dammit. It is modified. But I think I know how to get around it. One moment. I have to get something."
He stepped away and started fiddling with his pants pockets before pulling out some kind of card.
"This oughta do it."
He came forward again and started tapping and swiping the card against the helmet.
"You're mocking me, human."
"Nope. Just-" BEEP. "There we go!"
The helmet suddenly loosened around her head, and he lifted it slowly off and took a step away while tucking it under his arm.
Her long deep pink hair flowed down around her shoulders and chest while her bangs hid most of her face from view.
"How's that, Lucy? Feel any better now that it's off?"
"... You're still standing there even after I told you I'd kill you."
"Trust, Lucy."
Lucy lifted her head, and her crimson red eyes peeked out from beneath her bangs.
"You're about as foolish a human as I've ever encountered to think you can trust me."
"I'm still alive, aren't I?"
"I can change that."
"I know you can. But even so, I trust you the same as I trust the other Diclonius who are under my care. None of you are monsters. And I don't believe you're inherently murderers either. You kill to protect yourselves, and to get back at the humans who've hurt you. But I don't want to hurt you, Lucy. All my life I've wanted to show others that there's someone out there who will care for them when the rest of the world turns its back. That's why I volunteered to come here, even if it was under false pretenses. I thought I'd be taking care of special needs children whose parents abandoned or gave up on them. And in a way, I think I'm still fulfilling that role. Almost all the Diclonius children here at the facility were willingly given up by their parents. And all of them need someone who's willing to step into the role their parents left behind. You know?"
What the hell was wrong with him? Diclonius needing someone to step into their parents' role? Ridiculous.
He tossed the helmet aside and turned to pick up her dinner plate, holding it up for her to see the spread. And she had to admit that it smelled really good... So much so that her mouth started watering, though she did everything she could to hide it and swallow the gathering saliva. Part of the meal looked familiar, too. Were those rice balls?
"You have to be starving. Go ahead. Eat up."
She wanted to...
"My meals have been poisoned before. How do I know this one isn't?"
He set the tray on his left hand and used his right to pick up one of the rice balls.
"Would it help if I took a bite first to prove it's safe?"
She said nothing. But her glare spoke volumes as he took a bite out of the rice ball, chewed, and swallowed.
"There. If it is poisoned them I'm going to suffer too. But if this sweet flavor is suffering, then I'd love to suffer more."
Damn this human! The rice ball was immediately lifted out of his hand and brought up to her mouth by one of her vectors. And she devoured it in short order. By the time she'd finished the last grain she stole a glance at him to see him smiling again.
"Is this funny to you?"
He shook his head.
"No, Lucy. I'm just happy that you've finally had the chance to eat real food again. Like I said before, I'm not a fan of the slop their automated feeder gives you. They say it's packed with everything you need. But it's just tasteless mush."
"How do you know what it tastes like?"
"Because I tried it myself. It was bland and had basically no taste to it whatsoever. It didn't even leave me feeling full when I was done, despite how much there was in the bowl."
He wasn't wrong. It was tasteless, and left them wanting more. Did he really eat it? Bah. Who cared anymore? She continued devouring bite after bite of the food on the tray until only a few scraps remained. Her belly was full for the first time in... She couldn't even remember when she was last full. But the satisfaction. The taste still on her tongue. There was a warm feeling flowing through her body as she let out a deep breath and looked up from beneath her bangs.
"Good?"
"... You have five seconds to leave the cage before I kill you."
"Message received."
He backed out of the cage and locked the door again.
"I'll have breakfast prepared for you tomorrow morning. Anything special you'd like?"
"No."
"Fair enough. I'll see you tomorrow morning, Lucy. Goodnight."
And with that, he was gone again leaving her, once again, in silence.
Why didn't you kill him?!
"I... Don't know."
You're letting that smile get to you, aren't you? He smiled at you like that too. And look where that got you.
"Leave me alone."
Don't start going soft on these humans. They don't deserve it. When he brings you your breakfast you need to kill him. Otherwise you're just going to get hurt again.
"Go. Away."
The voice ceased. It was the same as when she was a child after the puppy was killed. It urged her to kill and assured her it was justified. But part of her always knew it wasn't. But after everything she'd been through she couldn't be bothered to care anymore. The humans had hurt her enough. If they wanted mercy they should have given it to her when she asked for it. But now, it was too late. There was no mercy left in her to give.
He'd learn that tomorrow.