They were great! The community was pretty awesome and the fights got pretty insane sometimes. But the better members ended up leaving and the challenge died. :(
People get mad when I say it, but I absolutely hated Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica. I couldn't find anything excessively dark about it and ended up just getting really annoyed by all the friendship chatter.
Awhile back I was a big role player on another forum, but the forum was too small to sustain the larger, more popular role plays for very long. That, and the fact that most of the role plays I participated in were scantily made and mostly consisted of 1-on-1 fights, so I'm looking forward to...